There is no USDA price for a beef bone. The daily boxed beef report never carried one. The weekly variety meat report prices the feet and the tail and stops there. The retail ad report has no soup bone line. Bones are sold every week all the same, to pet food, to retail and to broth kitchens, and the price is whatever the packer's list and the buyer agree. This page is the map a buyer needs to read that list.
What the spec calls a beef bone
USDA's purchase specifications carry one bone item, Item No. 134, Beef Bones. The spec says it is any one or combination of shank, femur or humerus bones, sawed into sections of the length the buyer specifies, with marrow exposed on at least one end of each section. That is the whole spec. It names three long bones, it leaves the length to the buyer, and it insists on marrow showing.
The spec says nothing about neck bones, back bones, knuckles or tails. Those trade under their own names, and the names come from where they sit on the animal.
Which bone is which
Femur. The thigh bone, out of the round. It is the longest and thickest bone on the carcass, with a straight shaft full of marrow. When a list says marrow bones with no other word, this is the bone the buyer pictures, and femur-only is the dearer item.
Humerus. The arm bone, out of the chuck and brisket end. Shorter and thicker-walled than the femur, with marrow in the shaft. It goes into mixed marrow bones alongside femur.
Shank bones. The lower leg, fore and hind, below the knee and hock. The hind shank is its own IMPS item for the meat on it. Sawed across, the shank bone and its meat is the osso buco cut. Bare, it is a soup bone.
Knuckle bones. The joint ends of the long bones, the ball and socket of the hip and the knee ends. They are spongy rather than hollow, with cartilage on the faces, and they give up collagen rather than marrow. A broth cook wants knuckles for body and marrow bones for flavor, which is why a broth pack usually has both. Sawed into pieces, cut knuckle bones are a tray item in ethnic markets. Whole, they are the cheapest bone on the list.
Neck bones. The cervical vertebrae, out of the chuck when the neck is boned. Bare, they are irregular and cheap, about level with the knuckle and a shade above it. With the meat left on they are a different item on the list, meaty neck bones, and they are worth much more than the bare bone. The pork version has its own page.
Back bones. The vertebrae left after the rib and loin are boned out, also called feather bones from the shape of the thoracic ones. Little marrow, some meat between the fingers of bone.
Tail and feet. The two bones USDA does price, on the weekly variety meat report. The oxtail page covers the tail. Feet print as bleached or unbleached and skin-on.
The order of value
Four items cover most of the trade, and they price in a fixed order: knuckle bones cheapest, with bare neck bones about level with them or a shade above, then mixed marrow bones, then femur-only, then canoe-cut femur, the thigh bone split along its length so the marrow lies open in a trough, the dearest bone there is. Inside the marrow bones the length sets the price, and not in the order a newcomer expects.
| Cut | What it is | Where it sits |
|---|---|---|
| 2 inch | mixed bones, sawed into short rounds | dearer than 4 inch: every saw cut is labor and a hand near a blade |
| 4 inch | mixed bones, the standard marrow bone | the everyday item, femur and humerus together |
| 6 inch center-cut femur | the middle of the thigh bone only, no knuckle ends | the best of the rounds, and femur-only costs more than mixed |
| canoe cut | a femur split lengthwise, marrow open along the bone | the top of the list |
| 9 inch and up | long sections | hard to sell, too large for the pot and the tray |
Two rules sit under that table. Femur-only costs more than mixed, because the femur is the straight, marrow-filled bone and mixed means whatever long bones the saw room had. And shorter costs more than longer up to a point, because each extra cut is labor and risk in a room where the saw is the most dangerous tool. The 2-inch round is mixed bone, not femur. It carries its premium for the work, not the bone.
Who buys bones
Pet food. The volume buyer. Raw and frozen pet food makers take marrow bones and knuckles for chews and for grinding, and they take the mixed grades that a kitchen would not. This trade moves frozen, by the pallet and by the container, and for a packer or a trader it is the account that clears the saw room every week.
Retail. The meat case sells marrow bones in trays, mostly 2-inch and 4-inch rounds, soup bones and neck bones under their own labels, and cut knuckle bones in the ethnic markets. The retail ad report has never carried a bone line, so there is no store count or ad price to read, but the trays move all winter.
Broth kitchens. Pho, ramen and bone broth makers want the 6-inch center-cut femur for marrow and knuckles for collagen, and they want them clean and consistent. It is the best price on the list and the hardest account to win, because a broth kitchen buys from whoever it already trusts and changes slowly.
Rendering. Whatever does not sell as a bone goes to the renderer with the rest of the drop, and comes back as bone meal and tallow. That is the floor under every bone price, and it is low. The drop value page explains how the renderer's price reaches the packer.